What is the rule in the House of Representatives that prohibits Members from referring to
the Senate, except as "the other body?" How did this rule come about? Senators talk
about the House. Why doesn't the Senate have a similar rule? - 5/3/00
The rule you mention is House Rule XIV, which deals with decorum in debate. Clause 1 of that
rule prohibits certain, but not all, references to the Senate and to Senators. The prohibition was
put in place in order to avoid verbal misunderstandings which might lead to strained relations
between the two chambers. While it is in order to refer to the Senate or actions of the Senate in a
neutral way, it is out of order to make critical comments about the Senate or its members. Also
prohibited are characterizations of individual Senators or their motivations. For example, it
would be all right for a House member to say: "The Senate passed the bill yesterday with several
amendments." However, it would not be appropriate to say, "After months of stalling, the Senate
finally bothered to pass our bill but only after loading it up with lousy amendments."
There are several reasons for regulating mentions of the Senate and its Members. First is the
tradition stated by Thomas Jefferson in his "Manual of Parliamentary Practice," which notes that
in a bi-cameral system each chamber should act independent of the other, and not be influenced
by the other's proceedings. At its heart, bi-cameralism encourages the check and balances that
come from the differences, and not the similarities, between the two bodies.
A second Jeffersonian principle is that the relationship between the two chambers should be
marked by civility and reciprocal courtesy, known as "comity." Jefferson warned that referring to
proceedings in the other body might lead to a misunderstanding and a subsequent breach in the
relationship between the two. The sometimes colorful history of Congress suggests that
Jefferson's concern was not unfounded. On a famous occasion in 1856, a Member of the House
assaulted a Senator in the Senate chamber after taking exception to words the Senator had spoken
in debate. The Senator was so seriously wounded, he could not return to work for 3 years.
Although they are not required to, it has become House tradition for Members to use "the other
body" instead of "the Senate," and "a Member of the other body," instead of "Senator Y."
However even using such generic terminology may not suffice to meet decorum standards. The
Chair may still call to order a Member who is impugning the motives of a Senator, disparaging
the character of a Senator, urging the Senate to take a certain action, or characterizing an action
already taken by the Senate, even if cloaked in "other body" vocabulary.
The Senate has no standing rule prohibiting references to the House of Representatives or its
Members. However, the Senate's presiding officer has on numerous occasions been asked to
admonish Senators making critical or disrespectful remarks about the House or House Members.
A combination of self-restraint and internal policing has prevented House references from
becoming a problem for the Senate. In fact, the rules of the Senate prohibit remarks in only two
categories: Senators may not "refer offensively to any State of the Union," nor may they "impute
to another Senator any conduct or motive unworthy or unbecoming a Senator."